Private mesh VPNs
Tailscale alternatives compared
Tailscale links your devices in a private network. To use it, you sign in with an account such as Google or Microsoft, and Tailscale runs the server that manages your network. These five tools do the same job in different ways.
Words used on this page
- Sign-in is how a person or device proves who it is before joining a network.
- A control server tells your devices who is in the network and how to reach each other. Your traffic does not have to pass through it.
- Self-hosted means you run the software on your own server instead of using the company’s service.
- An exit node, or exit, is a device that sends your internet traffic out to the web for you, like a regular VPN server. Websites see the exit’s address, not yours.
The options at a glance
| Product | Account and sign-in | Control server | Open source | Free tier and price | Exit nodes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nostr VPN | No account or login. Each device creates its own key, and the network’s admin approves who joins. Joining ↗ | None to run. Devices find each other through Nostr relays and trust a member list signed by the admin. How it works → | Yes. MIT license. License ↗ | Free, with no subscription. Optional paid exits charge per byte in Bitcoin. Paid exits ↗ | Yes: your own devices, a WireGuard VPN you already use, or experimental paid exits from independent providers (not on iPhone). Exits ↗ |
| Tailscale | An account with Google, Microsoft, GitHub, Apple, Okta, OneLogin, or another OIDC provider. No email sign-up. Sign-in options ↗ | Hosted by Tailscale. The server is closed source. Details ↗ | Partly. The core client is open source. The Windows, macOS, and iOS apps and the server are closed. Open source ↗ | Free for up to 6 users with unlimited devices, for non-commercial use. Paid plans from $8 per user per month. Pricing ↗ | Yes, on all plans. Mullvad exits are an add-on at $5 per month for every 5 devices. Exit nodes ↗ |
| Headscale | No outside account needed. The admin creates users on the server; devices join with a login link or a pre-made key. OIDC sign-in is optional. Joining ↗ | Self-hosted. It replaces Tailscale’s server and works with the official Tailscale apps. Overview ↗ | Yes. BSD-3-Clause license. License ↗ | Free software. You run and pay for the server. Project ↗ | Yes. A device offers to be an exit, and the admin approves it. Exit nodes ↗ |
| NetBird | Cloud: Google, Microsoft, GitHub, or email. Self-hosted: built-in local users, or your own identity provider. Self-hosting ↗ | Hosted by NetBird, or self-hosted on your own server. Cloud vs self-hosted ↗ | Yes. The client is BSD-3-Clause; the server parts are AGPLv3. Some self-hosted features need a commercial license. License ↗ | Free cloud plan for up to 5 users and 100 machines. Paid plans from €6 per user per month. Pricing ↗ | Yes, through a device you choose as the routing peer. Exit nodes ↗ |
| ZeroTier | A ZeroTier Central account for hosted networks. A self-hosted controller is managed through its local API instead. Getting started ↗ | Hosted ZeroTier Central, or your own controller. Business use of your own controller needs a commercial license. Controller license ↗ | Partly. The client is MPL-2.0. The controller is source-available, not open source. License ↗ | Free for 10 devices, one network, and one admin, for non-commercial use. Paid plans from $18 per month. Pricing ↗ | Yes, set up by hand: add a default route, set up forwarding on a Linux gateway, and allow it on each device. Full tunnel guide ↗ |
| Nebula | No account. Each host gets a certificate from a certificate authority you create. Quick start ↗ | None. You run “lighthouse” servers that help hosts find each other. Defined Networking offers a hosted version. Overview ↗ | Yes. MIT license. License ↗ | Self-hosted is free. The hosted version is free for up to 100 hosts, then $1 per host per month. Pricing ↗ | Not documented. “Unsafe routes” reach other private subnets, but the docs don’t cover sending all internet traffic through another host. Routes ↗ |
Published by the Nostr VPN project, not an independent review. Nostr VPN details refer to v4.1.20. Other products were checked on November 14, 2026, against their official pages; prices and plans change, so check them before you buy.
Who each one fits
Nostr VPN
You want a free private network for your devices, a small group, or AI agent hosts, with no account and no server to look after. It is newer than the others here and has no single sign-on or central access rules, so try it on two devices first. The v4.1.20 release notes list known issues.
Tailscale
You want a finished, managed product and are happy to sign in with an existing account. For a company that already uses Google Workspace, Microsoft, or Okta, it is often the easiest place to start. Sign-in options ↗
Headscale
You like Tailscale’s apps but want to run the server yourself, for a home lab or a small group. It runs one network per server, and the project says it is not enterprise software. It is not made by Tailscale Inc.
NetBird
You want Tailscale-style features, such as single sign-on, access rules, and exit nodes, with the choice to run the whole service yourself under an open-source license.
ZeroTier
You want a hosted service with a small free plan for personal devices, or a business plan with a commercial license. Read the controller license before you self-host it for work.
Nebula
You manage servers, are comfortable with certificates and config files, and want a network with no central server. Its hosted version, Managed Nebula, adds a web console and single sign-on.
When another option beats Nostr VPN
- Your company signs in through one identity provider and needs access rules managed in one place. Tailscale, NetBird, and Managed Nebula are built for this.
- You already use Tailscale and want to keep its apps while running your own server. Use Headscale. Nostr VPN cannot join an existing Tailscale network.
- You need WireGuard between devices to match existing tools. Tailscale and NetBird use WireGuard for the mesh. Nostr VPN’s mesh uses FIPS, and supports WireGuard only for internet traffic leaving the mesh.
Nostr VPN fits when you want none of that: no account to create, no server to run, and no subscription for your own network. See the full Nostr VPN and Tailscale comparison for platforms, privacy, and speed.
Looking for a regular privacy VPN you can pay for in Bitcoin instead? See Nostr VPN, Mullvad, and Obscura compared.
Common questions
Which Tailscale alternatives are fully open source?
Of the five here, Headscale (BSD-3-Clause), Nebula (MIT), and Nostr VPN (MIT) are open source. NetBird is open source too, with its server parts under the AGPLv3, though some self-hosted features need a commercial license. ZeroTier’s client is open source, but its controller is source-available, not open source.
Which Tailscale alternatives work without an account?
Nostr VPN and self-hosted Nebula need no account. Headscale and self-hosted NetBird let you create users on your own server, so no outside account is needed either, but you run that server.
Is Nostr VPN free?
Yes. Connecting your own devices is free and needs no wallet. Bitcoin is only for the optional, experimental marketplace of paid exits, which is not on iPhone.
Try it with two devices
Start with a private connection. No account or payment needed.